Deliberative Democracy Consortium eBulletin, v.5, no.3; August 21, 2006
--------------------------
After
a hiatus of several months, the eBulletin is back! First, please welcome
the Deliberative Democracy Consortium's new director Matthew Leighinger.
Matt replaces outgoing DDC Executive Director Tonya Gonzalez who left in
May. Tonya is pursue her passions in the media and media reform in
Washington, DC. Matt comes to the DDC with deep experience in building
deliberative democracy at the community and national level, having worked for a
long time with the Study Circles Resource Center. Matt's first book, "The
Next Form of Democracy: How Expert Rule is Giving Way to Shared Governance --
and Why Politics Will Never Be the Same" is available from Vanderbilt University
Press
(http://www.vanderbiltuniversitypress.com/bookdetail.asp?book_id=4048).
Congratulations, and welcome Matt!
The next
edition of the eBulletin will be September 15. Please send in your news and
updates from the
field.
============ In
Memoriam ============ Iris
Marion Young, a leading philosopher called by a colleague “one of the most
important political philosophers of the past quarter-century,” died in her
home Tuesday, Aug. 1 after a year-and-a-half long fight with cancer. She was
57. Young, Professor in Political Science at the University of
Chicago since 2000, was known for her work on theories of justice, democratic
theory and feminist theory. A complete remembrance is posted to the
University of Chicago
website: http://www-news.uchicago.edu/releases/06/060802.young.shtml
1
| [CONFERENCE] Deliberative Democracy Panels at
APSA -------- David
Booher, director of the Collaborative Democracies Network, has identified
several panels at this year's meeting of the American Political Science
Association that should be of interest. For more information about
the program please
visit: http://www.apsanet.org/mtgs/program/index.cfm
-
Deliberation, Opinion, and Participation (Kathleen Knight, Barnard
College-Columbia University; Tali Mendelberg, Princeton
University) - An Experimental Study of Democratic
Deliberation: The Limits and Potential of Citizen Participation (Shawn W.
Rosenberg, University of California,
Irvine) - The Nature and Origins of Attitude
Change in a Citizen Deliberative Assembly (Patrick
Fournier, Université de Montréal; André
Blais, Université de Montréal; R. Kenneth Carty,
University of British Columbia) - Extremists or
Good Citizens? The Political Psychology of Public Meetings and the Dark Side of
Civic Engagement (Christopher F. Karpowitz, Princeton
University) - Political Talk and Political
Participation: Does Who You Talk to Matter? (Casey A. Klofstad, University
of Miami; Jonathan McDonald Ladd, Georgetown
University)
To learn more about the upcoming
conference, visit APSA
online: http://www.apsanet.org/mtgs/program/index.cfm
2
| New Activity on the d-d.net
Blog -------- A
new corps of outstanding thinkers and doer's have been busy recently on the
Deliberative Democracy Consortium's blog
(http://www.deliberative-democracy.net/blog/).
Recent topics have included political moderation and the meaning of Senator Joe
Lieberman's loss in Connecticut (Peter Levine); populism and the undermining of
expertise in Kansas (Peter Levine); and how the brain helps partisans admit no
grey (Joe Goldman).
Check out these and
other articles, and join the discussions at
http://www.deliberative-democracy.net/blog/
3
| [CONFERENCE]
PlaceMatters06 -------- Planners,
technology innovators, theorists - all will come together in Denver October
19-21 to share their insights in the ways we can build vibrant, sustainable
communities through evolving forms of community participation. This year's
conference has several sessions that should be of particular interest to
deliberative democrats, among
them: - Turning on the Lights: Civic
Engagement in Energy Facility
Siting - Stories that Connect: The
Role of Media in Local and Regional
Planning - eParticipation: Technology and
the Future of Collaborative
Decision-Making
For more information about
the conference, please
visit: http://www.placematters.org/
4
| [PAPER] "What Happened on Deliberation
Day?" -------- [From
the d-d.net blog via Mike Wieksner] In a recent working paper for the
American Enterprise Institute/Brookings Institution Joint Center,
scholars David Schkade, Cass R. Sunstein, Reid Hastie conclude that, based
on the results of "a kind of Deliberation Day" held in Colorado,
deliberation "produced group polarization, in the distinctive form of
ideological amplification." These results fly in the face of everything a
practitioner will tell you. Read the full report to learn more about how
these findings were
produced. http://www.aei-brookings.org/publications/abstract.php?pid=1097
5 |
Can Consensus Be Achieved on Hard
Choices? -------- [From
the d-d.net blog via Mike Wieksner] That was the gist of the question
behind a recent experiment in deliberation conceived by The Brookings
Institution, the Heritage Foundation, and the Concord Coalition and carried out
by Viewpoint Learning. Three deliberative sessions of a dozen participants
each were carried out in Kansas City, San Diego, and Philadelphia.
According to a recent New York Times article, "Participants in the session were
given a whirlwind tour of the nation’s fiscal woes and then prodded to
find out what solutions they could — and could not — agree
on... The question for the researchers was this: do American voters, in
their diversity and their focus on self-interest, share any consensus about
making hard choices, or even on the need to make hard
choices?"
Read the full article online
at: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/30/business/yourmoney/30view.html?ex=1156305600&en=9d9d93297b7e4858&ei=5070
6 |
Table of Free
Voices -------- Nearly
10,000 questions from people around the world, winnowed down to 100, will be
posed to some of the world's luminaries on Sept. 9. Read by the American
actor Willem Dafoe in Bebelplatz Square in Berlin, these questions will
address topics from national security to personal values, racism to
environmental concerns and enable ordinary citizens and leading
intellectuals to engage in a discussion of international issues.
According to one of the project's visionaries, Dr. Ceasar L. McDowell of
MIT's Center for Reflective Community Practice, “We're launching what
we think will be an infrastructure for a global community of
citizens.”
Read more about the Table
of Free Voices and droppingknowledge.org
online: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14216322/
7 |
Ontario Citizens Assembly on Electoral
Reform -------- On
August 15th, 103 citizens from the Canadian province of Ontario were appointed
by the Minister Responsible for Democratic Renewal. The Assembly, composed
of 52 women and 51 men, were selected randomly from the Permanent Register of
Electors for Ontario and will come together for their first meeting on September
9, 2006. The Ontario Citizens Assembly on Electoral Reform, based on the
reknown British Columbia Citizens Assembly, will study Ontario's electoral
process, consult the public on what it values most in its electoral system, and
recommend whether Ontario should keeps its present system or adopt a new
one.
Read more about the Ontario Citizens
Assembly online
at: http://www.citizensassembly.gov.on.ca
8 |
Regional Development Strategy Launches Deliberative
"Choicebooks" -------- Voices
& Choices, a three-year economic revitalization initiative of the Fund for
Our Economic Future, launched a massive public education campaign in the region
to help residents learn about the tough choices facing the region and to vote
for the actions they think should be taken. The Choicebooks, developed by
Dialogue Circles, tackle six separate issues identified by more than 17,000
citizens and leaders alike as priorities for the region through community
discussions and workshops. The issue areas are: public school
financing, government, a 21st century workforce, race and inequality,
the business environment, and sprawl. Participants prioritize their
recommended actions by allocating limited "NEO Bucks" in each category of
solutions.
View the Choicebooks online
at: http://www.voiceschoices.org/choicebook
9 |
New Online Consultation Products by Dialogue by
Design -------- Dialogue
by Design, one of the UK's leading developers of online consultation solutions,
has developed two new products in 2006. "Smart Panel" (TM) offers a way to
collect qualitative data from large, representative sample of the public online
and offline using nearly identical comment-driven processes. "Smart
Dialogue" (TM), an online consultation process, uses apparently similar online
forms to collect information from the public through a series of structured
questions.
View these and other products
from Dialogue by Design
at: http://www.dialoguebydesign.net/
10 |
Reflective Democracy, Deliberative Democracy, and the American
Narrative -------- In
his recent work, "American Mythos: Why Our Best Efforts to Be A Better Nation
Fall Short," the Princeton University sociologist Robert Wuthnow
discusses American stories --"narratives about individualism, immigration,
success, religion, and ethnicity" -- and how they both advance and hinder our
progress as a nation. Among the point he covers is the notion of
deliberative democracy and something he calls "reflective democracy, which holds
that, "whether a person is in a group or alone, that person has a responsibility
to think critically about the values on which the society is
based."
Learn more about this and other
insights on the American narrative at Princeton University Press
online: http://www.pupress.princeton.edu/titles/8140.html
11
| IAP2 and Kettering Foundation Conduct Joint Decision-making
Research -------- [Snipped
from IAP2.org] In early 2005 the International Association for Public
Participation and The Kettering Foundation began work on a joint research
project that explores public-government decision making in seven country/regions
of the world: Africa, Australasia, Canada, Latin America, Southeast Asia,
UK/Western Europe and the United States.
The intent behind “Painting
the Landscape” reflects the larger strategic missions of both IAP2 and the
Kettering Foundation. For IAP2, this research project will lay a foundation for
future research initiatives on behalf of the organization’s 1,000 members
worldwide. The project also supports the Kettering Foundation’s research
with professional administrators and public officials who see that utilizing key
democratic practices to bridge the gap between the public and the formal
institutions of government is essential to their
work.
For more information about "Painting
the Landscape," visit IAP2
online: http://www.iap2.org/displaycommon.cfm?an=1&subarticlenbr=150
|