Deliberative Democracy Consortium eBulletin, v.5, no.5; November 10, 2006
--------------------------
For new ideas and discussion about innovations and issues impacting the field of
deliberative democracy, please join the DDC blogger corps at
http://www.deliberative-democracy.net/blog.
Recent entries include dispatches from Taylor Willingham of Texas Issues Forums
on new tools, Matt Leighninger of the DDC on "Citizens at the Center," and
AmericaSpeaks' Joe Goldman offers some reflection -- and photos -- from New
Orleans.
Also, be sure to visit the Journal
of Public Deliberation's practitioner and scholar editions online at:
http://www.auburn.edu/jpd/
and http://services.bepress.com/jpd/.
Recent contributions from Jane Mansbridge, John Gastil, and Jim
Snider.
FInally, we'd like to increase our
reader base. If you value the eBulletin as a resource, please pass it along to
your colleagues and encourage them to subscribe
at http://www.deliberative-democracy.net/ebulletin/
Many
thanks,
lars hasselblad
torres -- editor@deliberative-democracy.net
*****
1 |
[Study] The Job of Public Sector Management is to Maximize
Deliberation -------- Not
quite, but the Work Foundation in the UK has issued a new report that urges
policy-makers endorse 'public value' over mainstay concerns of 'consumer' choice
and satisfaction with public services. In their report, "Deliberative
Democracy and the Role of Public Managers," the authors Louise Horner, Rohit
Lekhi, and Ricardo Blaug argue that public sector manager's sense of connection
with the public is essential to the legitimacy and responsiveness of their
organization. Legitimacy and responsiveness, the authors suggest, lie at
the center of public service value and that such value is created when
agencies involve and interact with the public to design, plan, provide and
evaluate service provision. This, one must conclude, is where deliberative
democracy offers lessons and insight to the public management
sector.
Access the report
here: http://www.theworkfoundation.com/products/publications/azpublications/publicvaluefinalreport.aspx
2 |
[Conference] Dialogue and Lessons from Democratic Governance at
NLC -------- As
part of the Leadership Training Institute at the National League of Cities
conference (Reno, Nevada December 5-9), there will be a full-day workshop called
"Building Inclusive Communities through Democratic Governance."
NLC describes a workshop in which, "Participants in this seminar will
learn more about how these ideas support one another, and find out about
tools and structures they can use in their own communities.
Participants will take part in a sample dialogue on cultural difference,
extract lessons from a number of democratic governance projects, and hear
from elected officials about the lessons they have learned in doing this
work. Members of the Democratic Governance and Equity and Opportunity
Panels will serve as presenters, facilitators, and panellists. There will
be substantial opportunities for participants to learn from the Panel
members, and from each other, in
small-group discussions."
For more
information please
visit: http://www.nlc.org/Newsroom/Nation_s_Cities_Weekly/Weekly_NCW/2006/10/23/12412.cfm
3 |
[Book] DDC Executive Director Book
Tour -------- Matthew
Leighninger, Director of the Deliberative Democracy Consortium, has hit the road
to discuss his new book, "The Next Form of Democracy," (with a forward by former
US Senator Bill Bradley). Matt will be a guest for an author's
luncheon (a book talk) on December 12th at the NeighborWorks America
Training Institute in New Orleans.
(www.nw.org). "The Next Form of
Democracy: How Expert Rule Is Giving Way to Shared Governance...and Why Politics
Will Never Be the Same" is a tour through the opening landscape of American
civic engagement. Angela Blackwell, President of PolicyLink, writes that
in his new book, Matthew, "contributes immensely to our understanding of the
true meaning and real challenges of participatory democracy. He explores the
intersection of race and regional planning and development and exposes the
failure to create a society in which everyone can participate and prosper. This
is an important book for policymakers, advocates, and all those committed to
achieving the promise of democracy."
To learn
more about "The Next Form of Democracy," visit Amazon.com. To find out
about where he's speaking about his book, contact Matt directly
at mattleighninger@earthlink.net
4 |
[Conference] IAP2: Décision
Montréal -------- November
10-15, Montreal will be host to the International Association for Public
Participation's 2006 conference. This year's conference is marked by
keynote presentations from a range of perspectives, including WorldChanging.com
founding editor Jamais Cascio, the planner John Forester from Cornell, the
action artist Annie Roy, and Youth Action Network coordinator Michelle
Dagnino.
For more information about this
year's vibrant program, visit
http://www.iap2.org
5 |
US-Canada Federal Learning Network
Proposed -------- During
the annual conference of the International Association for Public Participation
(IAP2) a small group of public participation proponents will gather to scope out
a knowledge exchange between federal managers in the US and managers in
Canada. The purpose of the exchange is to share and develop knowledge
around effective public involvement practices in government. This kick-off
meeting, which will be held in Montreal November 14, will be an effort to gauge
interest and plan potential next steps.
To
join the conversation or to learn more, contact Matt Leighninger
at mattleighninger@earthlink.net
6 |
[Conference] Americans for the Arts
2007 -------- Americans
for the Arts announces a call for session proposals for its 2007 annual
convention, Risk & Reward: Balancing Acts in Arts and Community, in Las
Vegas, NV, June 1-3, 2007. In particular, Animating Democracy is
requesting proposals for a track of civic engagement sessions, which will
explore how the arts offer fresh sparks, welcoming invitations, needed
spaces, and new forms of civic participation. From volunteering to voting,
from community building to community healing, from issue awareness to
social action-the arts can facilitate participation in community and
political life and, by doing so, help people express their citizenship.
What are best practices for artists, arts organizations, and arts councils
working in the civic realm? How can we focus our civic intent for maximum
civic impact?
Americans for the Arts seeks
session proposals that take chances with topics, perspectives, and formats.
The submission deadline is December 1, 2006. For more details on how to
submit, visit
http://www.AmericansForTheArts.org/convention.
7 |
[Resource] Wise Democracy
Victoria -------- Wise
Democracy Victoria is a group of citizens concerned about the state of democracy
- in Victoria, in British Columbia, in Canada, and on the planet. The mission of
Wise Democracy Victoria is to seek out and investigate processes that can
enhance the scope, collabarativeness, and co-intelligence of democratic systems.
Wise Democracy Victoria comprises a growing number of people who realize
that better governance cannot be expected unless fundamental changes are
made to existing systems.
There are
several upcoming events in Victoria, BC including Friday, November 10th an
Introduction to Wisdom Councils that will feature Tom Atlee, author of "The
Tao of Democracy," and Jim Rough, author of Society’s Breakthrough, who
will introduce two key innovations in democratic participation: "Dynamic
Facilitation" and the "Wisdom
Council."
For more information, contact
Caspar Davis at prana4@shaw.ca or George
Sranko at
geo@jollytoad.co
8 |
[Resource] Canadian Policy Research Network Explores Health, Education and Civic
Engagement -------- "Citizens:
An Underused and Undervalued Asset in the Pursuit of Improved Health Care and
Delivery," a new report from CPRN, makes the case for why regional health
authorities in New Brunswick should give citizens a permanent place at their
health policy table. The author, Mary Pat MacKinnon, Director of CPRN’s
Public Involvement Network, clarifies the definition of citizen engagement as
she applies the concept to the development of health policy. The article was
originally published for the New Brunswick Healthcare Association, in the May
2006 edition of Health Matters. To access or download a copy, please
visit: http://www.cprn.org/en/doc.cfm?doc=1551
Last
Spring, experts and delegates from 12 countries met in Copenhagen to discuss the
impact of education on health and social and civic engagement. The OECD’s
Centre for Educational Research and Innovation (CERI) has published several
papers from that symposium. In one of them, Grounding in a Broader Framework of
Determinants of Health, CPRN’s Family Network Director, David Hay, gives a
critical analysis of the project’s review of literature that examines the
hypothesis that education has an impact on health. To access the proceedings of
the Copenhagen symposium, please
visit: http://tinyurl.com/yygrcn.
To download David Hay’s paper,
visit: http://tinyurl.com/se7jc
9 |
[Survey] Policy Consensus Initiative on Deliberative Democracy, Stakeholder
Decision-making, and Community
Problem-solving -------- The
Policy Consensus Initiative (PCI) is conducting a survey to gather examples of
where citizen engagement strategies have been used in combination with either
community problem-solving or multi-stakeholder dispute resolution. (An
example of such a combination would be a project that was identified in a public
forum and implemented through a community group or a stakeholder group.)
The results will be shared with participating
organizations.
To complete the survey, please
visit:
http://www.surveymonkey.com/s.asp?u=284742730370
10
| [Resource] Study Circles Guide to Inclusive Community Conversations on
Education -------- SCRC's
latest story booklet "Montgomery County, Maryland: Where a diverse
community comes together to work together to make schools better for all"
is the story of a study circle program in Montgomery County Public Schools
that's helping teachers, administrators, parents, and students address the
effects of racism on student achievement. In a school district of more than
140,000 students with 160 nationalities represented, study circles are
provide a bridge for schools to reach out to people of all backgrounds, and
a way for schools and community to work together to improve education
for all students.
The booklet can be
downloaded free of charge
at: http://www.studycircles.org//en/Resource.101.aspx)
or order a hard copy for
$1.50
11 | Groundbreaking EU
Consultations
Continue -------- On
the weekend of the 7 and 8 of October 2006, 200 citizens from all 25 Member
States met in Brussels to set the agenda for the national consultations to
take place in all EU Member States in the coming year. Three
topics for national level consultations emerged: Environment and energy;
Social welfare and family; Europe's global role, its external borders and
immigration.
In November and December
2006, two “test groups” of 40 citizens will meet in so-called
citizens’ juries to discuss and assess which kind of information
participants of the national consultations require to lead fruitful
discussions. Then, national consultations will take place from February to
March 2007 in all EU Member States. Citizens will discuss the
overarching question “What is needed to achieve the Europe we want?”
based on the three topics selected at the agenda-setting event in October.
At least four consultations will take place at the same time,
expected to create a "European atmosphere" and enable an exchange
of results and a true European dialogue across
locations.
A final consultation will take
place in May 2007. All 25 national results will be synthesised
and integrated to achieve as a result the “European
Citizens’ Perspectives”. The hand-over of this document
to European decision-makers will kick off the European follow-up process,
informing the public and all participants about the role of their results
in the formal political discussions on the future development of the
European Union.
For more information,
please visit:
http://www.european-citizens-consultations.eu For
queries, please contact: Felix Oldenburg, IFOK GmbH
atfelix.oldenburg@ifok.de
12 |
New Orleans UNOP Process Seeks to Engage Thousands of
Citizens -------- AmericaSpeaks,
a leader in the design and production of large-scale town meetings, is
supporting recovery in New Orleans by coordinating December 2nd's Community
Congress II, a key milestone in the Unified New Orleans Plan
process. UNOP is a six-month planning process established by the
Mayor, the New Orleans City Council, and the City Planning Commission to produce
a unified citywide plan for New Orleans by the beginning of 2007 that will guide
public and private investment for rebuilding the city. The December 2nd
town meetings are an historic opportunity for New Orleanians still living in
Atlanta, Baton Rouge, Dallas and Houston to join with those residents in New
Orleans for a truly inclusive meeting. New Orleanians in these five cities
will be connected together using interactive
technology.
According to the effort's
materials, this is one of the last opportunities for New Orleanians to voice and
vote on funding decisions for rebuilding the city, to give Mayor Nagin,
City Council and the City Planning Commission a list of priorities that reflect
the will of the people who want to live and return to New Orleans. The
completed plan will be submitted in January to local officials and then provided
to the Louisiana Recovery Authority.
More
information about the UNOP process is available at:
http://www.unifiedneworleansplan.com
13 |
[Resource] Newly Launched "International Journal of Public
Participation" -------- Have
a great piece but aren’t sure where to send it? John Gastil asks that you
consider the International Journal of Public Participation (IJP2), edited by
Kettering Foundation alumnus Michael Briand. The IJP2 is a peer-reviewed,
on-line, multi-disciplinary forum for the exchange of information among
researchers, practitioners, decision-makers, and citizens about public
participation and its impact around the world. The inaugural issue will appear
in March 2007. Articles should be as concise as possible (2000 to
5000 words in length), constructive, and based on evidence and careful argument.
They should use clear, direct language and avoid jargon. (For sample format
guides, see the Journal of Public Deliberation at
http://services.bepress.com/jpd/styleguide.html). The
deadline for receipt of manuscripts is December 29,
2006.
If you are interested in submitting
or proposing a contribution, please contact Michael Briand, Editor, at
mkbriand@internetconet.net.
14
| [Resource] NCDD's Impressive "Learning
Exchange" -------- The
National Coalition for Dialogue and Deliberation will be launching a new
resource called The Learning Exchange, which seeks to provide the most updated
and comprehensive collection of information related to dialogue and deliberation
-- anywhere! The Learning Exchange includes such goodies as the ability to
add your own resource; a coding system to help users identify things like how
new the resource is, whether it comes "highly recommended, and usefulness for
beginners; and RSS feeds to keep track of updates. NCDD's Learning
Exchange is still in beta (testing), but its live on the web for a sneak peek
with 1,673 resources in the database. You can access these resources at
http://www.thataway.org/exchange
NCDD
also welcomes your feedback on ways to improve the site. Please write to
Sandy Heierbacher with your questions and
feedback: sandy@thataway.org
15
| "Speed Deliberation" and Ideological
Amplification -------- A
few months ago, the scholar Cass Sunstein and his collaborators provoked
deliberative democracy proponents by releasing a study that argued deliberation
increases (or "amplifies") political polarization. This week, the New York
Times extends the debate with opinion writer John Tierney's "Must We Talk"
piece. The recent study, titled, "Political Deliberation and Ideological
Amplification: An Empirical Investigation" (published in August), sought to
diverge from most 'experimental' designs (presumably, the models of public talk
used by groups like the the Center for Deliberative Democrcy, AmericaSpeaks,
Study Circles, and others) by creating more "real world" conditions. To do
this, they asked 63 residents in Colorado to discuss three tough issues
-- global warming, affirmative action, and civil unions for same-sex
groups -- over the space of two hours. Each group was asked to come to
consensus in 15 minutes on each discussion topic and then they were individually
polled on their views. Based on this design, the scholars conclude that in
real-world political deliberation, distribution of opinions concentrates in the
extremes and most of opinion overlap evaporates. Ironically, some
commentators seemed to immediately agree -- or
disagree.
To join the fray, visit:
http://select.nytimes.com/2006/11/07/opinion/07tierney.html The
DDC's Matt Leighninger
responds: http://www.deliberative-democracy.net/blog/?p=168
|